Gag Orders in Singapore: Whose Identity Can be Protected?
What is a Gag Order and the Purpose of It?
To protect a witness or victim’s identity
A gag order is an order issued by the court in order to protect the identities of persons who are involved in court proceedings.
Such persons are usually the witnesses or victims involved in the case, and are often vulnerable persons, such as minors, and victims of sexual assault cases.
For example, in 2019, amidst the media frenzy surrounding the alleged murder of a 2-year-old girl whose remains were found in a Chin Swee Road flat, the court issued a gag order to prevent the victim’s identity from being revealed to the public.
Can the accused get the gag order?
Gag orders could also be issued to protect the identities of accused persons, but these gag orders are usually imposed with the main intent of protecting the victim involved rather than the accused person.
For example, in the case of the Chin Swee Road murder mentioned earlier, the gag order also protected the identities of the 2-year-old girl’s parents who were accused of killing her, since identifying them would have led to the identification of the victim.
If a case does not involve the need to protect a witness’ or victim’s identity, the courts will generally not grant accused persons a gag order. In 2019, when a 19-year-old polytechnic student attempted to get a gag order for himself after having been caught with multiple upskirt videos of unsuspecting women.
When making the request, the student said the gag order was required to avoid causing distress to his female classmates, and to protect his parents from the “unwanted spotlight” of his actions.
However, his request was denied by the judge who told him that the revealing of his identity was simply a consequence of his own actions that he would have to deal with.
To protect the identities of parties in a lawsuit
Gag orders can also be issued in civil cases. For example, gag orders are issued in all cases tried in the Family Justice Courts, such as divorces, to protect the identities of the people involved.
Similar to criminal proceedings, witnesses involved in civil trials may also be issued gag orders so they can testify without fear of their identity being revealed.
To protect state secrets
A gag order can even be used to protect state secrets, such as in cases where the Official Secrets Act has been violated.
For example, if a case involves presenting as evidence, secret official blueprints, that could prejudice Singapore’s safety if published, the court could issue a gag order to prevent the public and the media from publishing images or copies of the blueprints.
This article will further discuss:
- What are the gag order’s effects?
- Whether gag orders apply only to non-public court proceedings?
- How can a gag order be obtained?
- How long will the gag order last?
- What are the consequences of breaching a gag order?
- When can a gag order be lifted?
When a gag order is issued, every person, including the media and members of the public, should not publish any information, such as photographs, addresses, and or evidence that could lead to the identification of the person whose identity is being protected.
This is even if such information is detailed in the charge sheets, and is available to the media. Alternatively, such information may be redacted from court documents.
In fact, even the person being protected by the gag order should not contravene it by publicising his/her own identity.
Note that even if a person protected by the gag order has revealed his/her identity, this still does not give anyone the right to publish the person’s identity. A protected person’s identity may only be published if the gag order has been lifted.
Do Gag Orders Apply Only to Non-Public Court Proceedings?
Gag orders can be ordered for both proceedings that are being held publicly and those being held in camera (i.e. closed to the public).
Note that for proceedings held in camera, the court has the discretion to still allow journalists or other individuals, such as family members of the accused person, to attend the proceedings.
How Can a Gag Order be Obtained?
Parties can apply to the court for a gag order to be issued. Ultimately, however, the court has the discretion to decide whether to grant or reject the application.
In addition, from 1 July 2020 onwards, information or pictures that can identify young persons who have been arrested for an offence, or who are involved in court proceedings, legally cannot be published.
How Long Will the Gag Order Last?
What are the Consequences of Breaching a Gag Order?
If you breach a gag order issued by the State Courts, for example through posting a photograph of a witness in a trial on Facebook, you can be fined up to $5,000, or imprisoned for up to 12 months or both.
Breaching a gag order issued by either the High Court or the Court of Appeal, on the other hand, could land you with a fine of up to $5,000 or an imprisonment term of up to 3 years, or both.
Re-sharing of information revealing the identity of a protected person
If you have reposted or retweeted a post or tweet which contains information that breaches a gag order, you can also be charged and even suffer the same consequences as the original publisher of the information.
However, it remains to be seen as to how exactly action will be taken when a post becomes viral through multiple different reposts.
Breach of gag order by the protected person themself
Since a gag order applies to everyone, from members of the public to the media, this technically means that even the person whose identity has been gagged cannot reveal it.
When Can a Gag Order Be Lifted?
Gag orders can be lifted in various instances, such as where:
- The identity of the protected person has already been revealed to the public, making the order useless, or where
- The court is convinced that there is no longer any need to protect the person’s identity (such as where the person has passed away).
In particular, a gag order imposed on an accused may be lifted if all victims and/or witnesses involved in the case agree to the risk that their identity may be revealed. However, it is very rare for a gag order to be lifted once it has been made.
If you have been the victim of a crime, obtaining a gag order on your identity is a possibility if you are afraid of it being publicly revealed during court proceedings.
If you have been accused of a crime, however, do note that it is highly unlikely that you will be granted a gag order, unless revealing your identity could lead to the identification of the victim(s) involved and there is a need to protect their identities.
To get expert opinion on whether you might be able to get a gag order on your identity, you may want to consult a criminal lawyer. The lawyer will be able to assess your case, seek a gag order on your behalf as necessary, and also help you get the best outcome for your case as is possible.
- Differences between Criminal Law and Civil Law
- Limitation Periods: What's the Deadline for Suing in Singapore?
- Mediation in Singapore
- Arbitration and Mediation: When They Can be Useful for Business Disputes
- 6 Things You Need to Know about Third-Party Funding in International Arbitration
- Can I Sue a Foreigner in Singapore?
- Should You Sue? 8 Things to Think About Before Suing
- What to Do If Someone Sues Your Singapore Business
- Arbitration: When and How to Arbitrate Business Disputes in Singapore
- How to Write a Cease and Desist Letter in Singapore
- Using Neutral Evaluation to Resolve Civil Disputes in Singapore
- Law on Writ of Summons in Singapore
- Engaging a Queen’s Counsel in Singapore
- Letters of Demand and Their Usages in Singapore
- Making a Claim in the Small Claims Tribunals in Singapore
- Security of Payment Act: Claiming Progress Payments for Construction Work Done
- Negotiating a Settlement in a Business Dispute
- What if I Cannot Find the Party I Want to Sue?
- First Meeting With Your Business Dispute Lawyer: What to Expect
- Received a "Without Prejudice" Letter? Here’s What It Means
- Admissibility of Evidence in the Singapore Courts
- Civil Litigation in Singapore
- Gag Orders in Singapore: Whose Identity Can be Protected?
- Default Judgments and Summary Judgments in Singapore
- Memorandum of Appearance in Singapore: What It is and How to File
- After the Lawsuit: Who Has to Pay Whom, and How Much?
- Affidavits in Singapore: What Are They & How to Prepare One
- How to Get a Writ of Seizure and Sale to Enforce a Judgment
- Subpoenaed to be a Court Witness in Singapore: What You Need to Do
- Who is an Expert Witness and How to Use Expert Evidence in Singapore
- Legal DNA Test: What is It For, How It’s Conducted, Cost & More
- Originating Summons: What It Is and How to File in Singapore
- Destroying and Tampering With Evidence in Singapore