Informal Debt Restructuring and Workout in Singapore
Cash flow and debt issues can be a significant worry for all businesses, but is more often a concern for Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) which may have lower cash reserves than larger corporations or less access to credit. Inevitably, not all businesses succeed but even sound businesses can sometimes suffer from liquidity stress depending on market forces. For the SME owner who wishes to save his under-performing business, one possible solution is entering into an informal workout and debt restructuring process.
What is Informal Debt Restructuring?
As mentioned, corporate debt restructuring is a process carried out when a business is facing difficulties paying its debts. In a “workout”, major creditors will take the initiative to work together to ensure the short-term viability of the debtor company so that there is a higher chance of their debts being repaid in full.
This will generally take the form of contractual arrangements where creditors may agree to extend the repayment period for loans, in exchange for guarantees from the company that it will reorganise its operations, or change key management personnel, in a way which the creditors feel would best help the debtor stay solvent.
As a secondary objective, creditors in a winding up will want to assess their relevant lending positions and the assets of the company so that they can estimate how much of their money they can get back if the informal debt restructuring process is insufficient to turn the company around.
How is it Different from Formal Debt Restructuring?
The Companies Act has 2 main categories of formal debt restructuring: judicial management and schemes of arrangement.
In judicial management, when a company is unable or likely to become unable to pay its debts but the interests of the creditors would be better served by its continuation as a going concern compared to winding up, a court may appoint a judicial manager, typically an independent accountant.
The effect of a judicial management order is to temporarily protect the company from any winding up or debt collection application. The judicial manager will then have full power over the assets of the company to ensure that spending is limited and any revenue is properly managed to help the company return to full solvency, and therefore be in a better position to repay creditors in future.
The aim is thus to turn the company around and increase its profitability, to improve the recovery and satisfaction of the debts of the company. But if this objective is not met, then the judicial manager may make a winding up application.
Read our other article for more information on judicial management in Singapore.
Schemes of arrangement
In a scheme of arrangement, creditors and/or shareholders of a company may voluntarily agree to vary their right to receive certain payments from the company. When the company is financially distressed, shareholders of a particular class may consider it better to accept a delay or even reduction to their right to receive their guaranteed dividends so as to secure the viability of the company as a going concern, for example.
In such a case, a court application is needed to make the scheme of arrangement binding on all members of that class. Typically, a three-fourths majority vote in favour from the relevant class of creditors/shareholders is needed before the court will approve the scheme of arrangement.
The company must also enter into a full and frank disclosure with regard to the company’s situation so that those who are voting on the scheme of arrangement are fully informed. If such information is not disclosed, then it may invalidate the scheme of arrangement.
Read our other article for more information on schemes of arrangement in Singapore.
How Do I Carry Out Such a Debt Restructuring Exercise?
There is no set way to carry out a debt restructuring. Corporate debt restructuring works best where all major creditors co-operate.
If a company is facing relatively minor financial stresses, asking individual creditors for more time on specific one-off payments may be possible but would not be appropriate for more serious financial difficulties.
In a workout, the creditors would likely want to see the accounts of the business concerned and fully understand how its different divisions function, where it is profitable, where it is making a loss, and where it can be more efficient. The creditors may mutually agree to postpone contractual payments due to them if the company agrees to cut costs in a certain way, for example.
If creditors are not confident with the current management of the borrowing company, they may ask for changes to the management structure too, so that someone they perceive to be more effective can run the company better.
These variations to existing contractual obligations would normally take effect in the form of a contract novating (replacing) or modifying these obligations. Exceptionally, where some sort of gratuitous benefit is being conferred, it would need to be contained in a deed to be legally binding.
The degree to which a borrowing company is willing to accept creditor interference into its internal affairs would vary from case to case, depending on what the creditors are offering in return in terms of repayment holidays or interest moratoriums, for example.
Although there is no automatic shielding from suits to collect debts, which is the case for judicial management, the company or creditors can still ask the court for a stay of proceedings where a debt restructuring agreement is already in place. One key advantage of a workout or informal debt restructuring is that it gives the creditors and debtor more flexibility and, potentially, preserves the business as a going concern.
Is Informal Debt Restructuring Right for My Business?
Given the additional costs of court applications, the liability of the board and members of the debtor company and the relatively inflexible winding up procedure, a workout or informal debt restructuring should usually be the first option for any company facing cash flow stresses.
This is particularly so when the management knows that the business is fundamentally sound and has a good chance of fully recovering: this clearly benefits the company and its employees but is also beneficial to creditors who would prefer a steady income stream of debt repayments rather than having to go to court to claw back possibly only a small percentage of the full amount that they are owed.
A company in this position must be able to convince its creditors that it can recover and ought to negotiate and co-operate where possible. It is usually easier to do this where creditors are unsecured: as there is no underlying asset which they can sell off to get their money back, the best option for them is to support the borrowing business’ return to solvency so that they can then collect payment.
Whatever option is best for your business, debt restructuring is relatively complex so you may want to refer to our directory of corporate lawyers to find a lawyer to seek advice.
- Appointing Company Directors in Singapore: Eligibility, Process etc.
- Managing Director vs CEO in Singapore: Roles and Obligations
- Guide to Directors' Remuneration in Singapore
- Directors' Duties in Singapore
- Shadow Directors: Who are They and What Duties Do They Owe to the Company?
- How to Remove a Director from a Company in Singapore
- Removal and Resignation of Company Auditor in Singapore
- Appointing a Company Secretary: Roles and Responsibilities
- Appointing an Authorised Representative for Foreign Companies in Singapore
- Process Agents in Singapore
- 2 Ways to Remove a Singapore Company Shareholder ASAP
- Guide to Paid-Up Capital in Singapore (Is $1 Enough?)
- Preparing a Register of Shareholders for a Singapore Company
- How to Issue Shares in a Singapore Private Company
- Guide to Transferring Shares in a Singapore Private Company
- Your Guide to Share Certificates in Singapore: Usage and How to Prepare
- Shareholder Rights in Singapore Private Companies
- Shareholder Roles and Obligations in Singapore Companies
- Dividend Payments Guide for Singapore Business Owners
- Share Transmission: What Happens If a Shareholder Dies in Singapore?
- How to Reduce the Share Capital of Your Singapore Company
- Buy-Sell Agreements: How to Write & Fund Them in Singapore
- Oppression of Minority Shareholders
- Essential Regulatory Compliance Guide for Singapore Companies
- Dormant Companies and Their Filing Obligations in Singapore
- Anti-Money Laundering Regulations and Your Business: What You Need to Know
- Price-Fixing, Bid-Rigging and Other Anti-Competitive Practices to Avoid
- Legally Conducting Lucky Draws for Singapore Businesses
- Restaurant Inspection and Food Safety Rules in Singapore
- Does Your Company Need a Legal Team (In-House Counsel)?
- How to Change the Name of Your Singapore Company
- Can Directors be Liable for Company Debts in Singapore?
- Company Loans to Directors/Shareholders in Singapore
- 3 Types of Insurance Every Singapore Business Needs
- Creating and Registering Charges in Singapore: Guide for Companies
- Guide to Effective Business Continuity Planning in Singapore
- Business Asset Sale & Disposal in Singapore: How Do They Work?
- Business Partnership Disputes in Singapore: How to Resolve
- How to Commence a Derivative Action on Behalf of a Company in Singapore
- Business Will: How to Pass on Your Business to Your Successors in Singapore
- Record-Keeping Requirements for Singapore Companies
- Company Constitutions in Singapore and How to Draft One
- Company Memorandum and Articles of Association
- Company Resolutions: What are They?
- Board Resolutions in Singapore
- Minutes of Company Meeting in Singapore: How to Record
- How to Set Up a Register of Controllers
- How to Set Up a Register of Nominee Directors
- Guide to Filing Financial Statements for Singapore Business Owners
- Filing Annual Returns For Your Business
- Singapore Corporate Tax: How to Pay, Tax Rate, Exemptions
- Start-Up Tax Exemption Guide for New Singapore Companies
- GST Registration: Requirements and Procedure in Singapore
- What is Withholding Tax and When to Pay It in Singapore
- Singapore Influencers: Here's How to Calculate Your Income Tax
- Tax Investigation of Tax-Evading Business Owners in Singapore
- Small Business Accounting Services in Singapore
- Company Audits in Singapore: Requirements and Exemptions
- Suspect a PDPA Data Breach? Here's What to Do Next
- Must You Notify PDPC About a Data Breach in Your Business?
- Summary: Your Organisation's 10 Main PDPA Obligations
- Essential PDPA Compliance Guide for Singapore Businesses
- PDPA Consent Requirements: How Can Your Business Comply?
- Is It Legal for Businesses to Ask for Your NRIC in Singapore?
- Here's a 7-Step Plan for Companies to Prevent Unauthorised Disclosure When Processing and Sending Personal Data
- Cloud Storage of Personal Data: Your Business’ Data Protection Obligations
- GDPR Compliance in Singapore: Is it Required and How to Comply
- Appointing a Data Protection Officer For Your Business: All You Need to Know
- How Can Companies Dispose of Documents Containing Personal Data?
- Check the Do-Not-Call Registry Before Marketing to Singapore Phone Numbers
- How to Legally Install CCTVs for Home/Business Use in Singapore
- Is Web Scraping or Crawling Legal in Singapore?
- Legal Options If Employees Breach Confidentiality in Singapore
- Dealing with Defamation of Your Business: Can You Sue?
- Sending Email Newsletters That Comply With Singapore Law
- A legal guide to drafting a social media policy for your company
- Your Guide to a Media Release Form in Singapore
- Your Guide to an Influencer Marketing Agreement in Singapore
- Outdoor Advertising: How to Legally Display Public Ads in Singapore
- Voluntary Suspension of Business in Singapore: How to Handle
- Winding Up a Singapore Company: Grounds and Procedure
- Closing Your Singapore Business: What You Need to Settle
- Striking Off a Company
- Can a Company that Struck Itself Off the Register Later Apply to Restore Itself?
- Dissolution of partnerships in Singapore
- What Should a Creditor Do When a Company Becomes Insolvent?
- How to File a Proof of Debt Against a Company in Liquidation
- Insolvency: Claw-Back of Assets From Unfair Preference and Undervalued Transactions
- Validation of Payments Made by Companies Being Wound Up