When Can I Raise the Defence of Provocation in Singapore?
When someone is on the receiving end of provocative actions or words, and as a result kills the other party who had provoked him, will this be considered a defence?
This article will discuss:
What is the Defence of Provocation in Singapore?
In simple terms, provocation is an action or statement done/made with the intention to cause a reaction, especially anger or annoyance from the person being provoked.
In the context of law, provocation is a partial defence to murder found in Exception 1 to section 300 of the Penal Code. It can therefore be raised as a defence by someone who has been charged with murder.
Exception 1 to section 300 of the Penal Code provides that culpable homicide will not be considered as murder if the offender had, while deprived of the power of self-control by grave and sudden provocation, caused the death of:
- The person who gave the provocation; or
- Any other person by mistake or accident.
This defence recognises common human behaviour where individuals can, in limited situations, be emotionally overwhelmed to the point that they kill another person under conditions of extreme fear, sadness, depression or even jealousy.
What Happens If the Defence of Provocation is Successfully Established?
As mentioned above, provocation is only a partial defence to murder as opposed to a complete one. Hence, a person who successfully pleads this defence after being accused of murder will not be able to entirely avoid punishment. Instead, they will have their murder charge reduced to a charge of culpable homicide not amounting to murder, and be convicted of that reduced charge.
That said, this reduction in charge can literally mean the difference between life and death for the accused. This is because the maximum penalty for culpable homicide not amounting to murder is life imprisonment, which is a less severe sentence than the maximum penalty of death for the offence of murder.
You may learn more about the differences between murder and culpable homicide, including their penalties, in our other article.
Elements that Must be Established for a Successful Defence of Provocation
In order for the defence of provocation to succeed, there is a 2-stage test that must be satisfied.
- First, the accused has to prove that he had been deprived of his self-control by the provocation. In ascertaining “self-control”, the accused’s behaviour during the time of the offence would be of great evidential value. The loss of self-control has to be sudden and temporary, causing the accused to be so subject to passion as to make him lose control over his mind.
- Second, the provocation must have been “grave and sudden”, which involves the use of an objective “reasonable man” test. This test considers whether an ordinary person of the same gender and age as the accused, and sharing such of the accused’s characteristics would affect the gravity of the provocation, and if placed in the same situation as the accused, would have been so provoked as to lose his self-control.
In the case of Pathip Selvan s/o Sugumaran v Public Prosecutor, the accused managed to successfully raise the defence of provocation after being charged with murder for stabbing his girlfriend to death. The accused and the victim had had a tumultuous relationship where they fought over her infidelity, but eventually always reconciled. He even had plans to marry her, and bought her a “Thali” (Hindu nuptial chain) as a symbol of their relationship. Leading up to the incident, he had caught her kissing another man in bed and confronted her about it. While he was crying, she told him that “he is better than you in bed that is why I am after him”.
The court found that the accused’s being taunted in such a way, while already in a heightened emotional state, resulting in him losing self-control when he stabbed her. The fact that he had stabbed the victim in an entirely random and frenzied manner also suggested that the accused had lost self-control. Accordingly, the first stage of the test was met.
The second stage of the test, namely that the provocation must have been objectively grave and sudden, was also satisfied. The accused had had intensely passionate feelings for the victim and fully expected to reconcile with the victim after the latest confrontation. However, instead of seeking forgiveness for her infidelity as she had done in the past, the victim taunted him, provoking him into losing self-control and stabbing her almost immediately after.
The court found that this constituted grave and sudden provocation for the purposes of the second stage of the stage. With both stages of the test satisfied, the defence of provocation was made out and the accused was convicted of culpable homicide instead of murder.
When Will the Defence of Provocation Not be Available?
The accused will not be able to successfully raise the defence of provocation if it is shown that:
- The provocation had been self-induced (brought on/about by the offender himself).
- The provocation had been done in obedience to the law or by a public servant, within the exercise of powers given.
- An example of this would be when the accused is provoked by a police officer lawfully arresting him and hence kills the police officer. The defence of provocation would not be made available as the provocation had been lawfully done by a public servant.
- The provocation had been given by anything done in the lawful exercise of the right of private defence.
- An example of this would be when A attempts to punch B, but B, in exercising the right of private defence, holds A down to prevent him from doing so. A then becomes provoked and kills B in the process. This would constitute murder as the act of provocation was done in the right of private defence.
As seen from the above discussion, successfully raising the defence of provocation involves more than claiming that you had been provoked at the relevant point in time. There are strict legal criteria to be met, from establishing that you had in fact lost self-control at the material time, and also being able to convince the court that an ordinary person in your position would have similarly found the provocation grave and sudden. Proving the defence hence requires specialised expertise in the law that only a criminal lawyer will be able to provide.
If you have been charged with murder, you will automatically be assigned a lawyer under the Legal Assistance Scheme for Capital Offences (LASCO) to defend you in court if you don’t have a lawyer of your own. However, you may wish to consider engaging your own criminal lawyer if you have the means to do so.
By doing so, you will be able to look for a lawyer whom you feel can best represent your interests. When speaking to your lawyer, seek their advice on the defences available to you and how you should proceed with your case. In particular, they will also be able to advise on whether it is in your interests to raise the defence of provocation, or some other defence, in view of the severe penalties that may follow from being charged with murder.
- Singapore’s Extraterritorial Jurisdiction: What Does It Mean?
- Your Right to a Lawyer After Being Arrested in Singapore
- What to Do If Your Loved One is Under Police Investigation
- How to Write a Letter of Representation to AGC in Singapore
- What is Entrapment and is It Legal in Singapore?
- What Happens When You Voluntarily Surrender to the Police
- Juvenile Crime: What If Your Child is Arrested in Singapore?
- Seized Assets in Money Laundering Investigations: What Happens To Them?
- Tasers, Batons, Shields & Firearms: When Do the Police Use Them?
- Stopped by the Singapore Police For Spot Checks, Etc: What to Do
- What is the Appropriate Adult Scheme in Singapore?
- Police Investigation Process for Crimes in Singapore (4 Steps)
- Arrest Warrant Issued Against You in Singapore: What to Do
- Police Arrest Procedure in Singapore
- Arrestable and Non-Arrestable Offences in Singapore
- What Should You Do If You Witness a Crime in Singapore?
- Can the Public Make a Citizen's Arrest in Singapore?
- What to Do If You’re Being Investigated for a Criminal Offence in Singapore
- "Right to Remain Silent" to Singapore Police: Does It Exist?
- Police Custody in Singapore: What You Should Know
- Search Warrant: The Issuance and Execution of It in Singapore
- Penalties for Lying to the Authorities in Singapore
- Can You Say No to a Lie Detector Test in Singapore? And Other FAQs
- Surrender of Passport to the Police and How to Get It Back
- Extradition: What If I Flee After Committing Crime in Singapore
- Making Objections at Trial in the Singapore Courts
- When is a Witness Testimony Unreliable in Singapore?
- Burden of Proof in Criminal and Civil Cases in Singapore
- Falsely Accused of a Crime in Singapore: Your Next Steps
- What is Acquittal & How Can One Be Acquitted in Singapore?
- Using the Defence of Diminished Responsibility in Singapore
- Death of a Party in a Legal Case in Singapore: What Happens?
- The "Unusually Convincing" Test in "He Said, She Said" Cases
- How to Adjourn or Postpone a Criminal Court Hearing
- TIC: Guide to Charges Taken Into Consideration in Singapore
- Can I Use the Defence of Intoxication in Singapore?
- When Can I Raise the Defence of Provocation in Singapore?
- Writing Character References For Court: What’s Their Purpose?
- Giving False vs. Wrong Evidence: What’s the Difference?
- Can I Represent Myself in a Criminal Court Case in Singapore and How?
- Claiming Trial as an Accused
- Pleading Guilty in Singapore: Consequences & Withdrawal of Plea
- The Defence of Unsound Mind in Singapore: What is It?
- Gag Orders in Singapore: Whose Identity Can be Protected?
- Mitigation Plea: How to Plead for Leniency in Court in Singapore
- Recidivism: What Happens If You Reoffend in Singapore?
- Guide to Filing a Criminal Appeal in Singapore
- Criminal Motion: What is It and How to File One in Singapore
- Guide to Filing a Criminal Revision in Singapore
- Presidential Clemency in Singapore
- Repatriation or Deportation from Singapore: How Does It Work?
- Criminal Records in Singapore
- Visiting a Loved One in Prison or On Death Row in Singapore
- Getting Parole (Early Prison Release) in Singapore
- Fined for an Offence: What to Do If I Can't Afford to Pay Them?
- How Long Is Life Imprisonment in Singapore? And Other FAQs
- Corrective Training and Its Consequences in Singapore
- Consequences of Receiving a Stern Warning in Singapore
- Probation: Eligibility and Whether It Leaves a Criminal Record
- How Can Adult Offenders Get Probation in Singapore?
- Reformative Training in Singapore: When Will It be Ordered?
- Are You Eligible for a Mandatory Treatment Order (MTO)?
- Caning in Singapore: Judicial, School & Parental Corporal Punishment
- 7 Detention Orders in Singapore: When Will They be Ordered?
- Day Reporting Order: Eligibility and Offender's Obligations
- Ragging and Bullying: Their Penalties and What Victims Can Do
- Laws Protecting Informers/Whistleblowers in Singapore
- Counterfeit Medicine/Health Products: Redress for Victims in Singapore
- Breach of Protection Orders: What Can Victims Do?
- Using Your Right to Self-Defence When Attacked in Singapore
- Compensation for Crime Victims in Singapore: How to Obtain
- Rape Laws in Singapore and How Offenders Can Be Punished
- Sexual Misconduct in Singapore: Offences and What Victims Can Do
- Falsely Accused of Rape in Singapore: What to Do
- Incest and Family Sexual Abuse: Penalties and Victim Protection
- How are Sexual Offenders with Special Needs Penalised?
- Cybersexual Crimes in Singapore and Their Penalties
- Legal Age for Sex in Singapore and Common Sexual Offences
- Consent in Sexual Offences in Singapore and What Victims Can Do
- Accused of Molest: Outrage of Modesty in Singapore
- What Can Victims of Sexual Harassment in Singapore Do?
- What is the Law on Sexting in Singapore?
- Revenge Porn: What If Your Nudes are Leaked in Singapore?
- Crime of Voyeurism in Singapore (Penalties and Defences)
- Date Rape: What to Do If Your Drink Has Been Unlawfully Spiked?
- STDs: Can I Go to the Police If a Partner Infected Me in Singapore?
- Alcohol Breathalyser Test in Singapore: Can You Refuse it?
- Are Sex Toys and Sex Dolls Legal in Singapore?
- Singapore's Legal Smoking Age & Common Smoking Offences
- Is Vaping Illegal in Singapore?
- Legal Drinking Age and Drinking-Related Laws in Singapore
- Is Watching, Downloading or Filming Porn Illegal in Singapore?
- Child Pornography in Singapore: Offences and Penalties
- Laws on Procuring Sex Workers & Sexual Services in Singapore
- Singapore's Drug Laws: Possession, Consumption and Trafficking
- Gambling Legally (at Home, in Public or Online) in Singapore
- The Offence of Human Trafficking in Singapore and Its Penalties
- What is a Protected Area and Place in Singapore?
- Penalties For Buying Stolen Goods in Singapore
- Penalties for Committing Theft in Singapore
- Committing Robbery in Singapore: What are the Penalties?
- Penalties for Dishonest Misappropriation of Property in Singapore
- Vandalism Laws: Penalties for Damaging Property in Singapore
- Criminal Trespass in Singapore: What Happens If You’re Caught?
- Penalties for Littering Offences in Singapore
- What is a POFMA Correction Direction and How to Appeal
- Penalties for Cheating/Scamming and What Victims Can Do
- Penalties for Impersonating Someone and Victim Redress
- Singapore Fake News Laws: Guide to POFMA (Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act)
- Laws and Penalties for Doxxing in Singapore (With Examples)
- Tax Evasion in Singapore: Penalties and Examples
- Criminal Breach of Trust (CBT) in Singapore: What is It?
- All You Need to Know About Corruption in Singapore
- Anti-Money Laundering Laws and You
- 5 Things You Need to Know about Insider Trading
- Dishonest Assistance and Knowing Receipt: The Case of David Rasif
- Charged with a Traffic Offence in Singapore: What to Do
- DUI: Here are the Penalties for Drink-Driving in Singapore
- What Happens If You’re Caught Speeding in Singapore?
- Road Rage: What is It and How are Offenders Sentenced in Singapore
- Penalties for Dangerous Driving for Singapore Drivers
- Fatal Traffic Accidents: Are Drivers Always Punished?
- Guide to E-Scooter and PMD Laws for Singapore Riders
- Is it Legal for Drivers to Carpool in Singapore?
- Radicalisation and Terror Attack-Related Penalties in Singapore
- Causing a Public Nuisance in Singapore: What are the Penalties?
- Causing Public Alarm in Singapore: Examples & Penalties
- Public Assemblies and Processions in Singapore
- Misbehaving in Public: 5 Things You Need to Know
- Racial Enmity: Sections 298 and 298A Penal Code Explained
- Religious Cults in Singapore: Are they Illegal? Penalties & More
- Penalties for Financing Terrorist Operations in Singapore
- Penalties for Abetting Minors or Committing Crimes Against Them
- Misusing the Singapore Flag and Other National Symbols
- What are the Penalties for Committing Forgery in Singapore?
- Arson and Fire-Related Offences and Their Penalties in Singapore
- Offences Against the Dead and What Family Members Can Do
- Laws on Prohibited, Replica and Self-Defence Weapons
- Laws to Tackle High-Rise Littering in Singapore
- Penalties for Attempting to Commit a Crime in Singapore
- Penalties for Assaulting a Person in Singapore
- Expats Charged With Offences in Singapore: What to Expect
- What are the Penalties for Hiring Phantom Workers in Singapore?
- What Are Ponzi Schemes? Are They Illegal in Singapore?
- Modification of Cars, Motorcycles, Etc: Is It Legal in Singapore?
- Penalties for Illegal Immigration and Overstaying in Singapore
- Criminal Intimidation: Penalties for Making Threats in Singapore